Thoreau’s Insect Analogies: Or, Why Environmentalists Hate Mainstream Economists
Author(s)
Norton, Bryan G.
Abstract
Thoreau believed that we can learn how to live by observing nature, a view that appeals to modern environmentalists. This doctrine is exemplified in Thoreau’s use of insect analogies to illustrate how humans, like butterflies, can be transformed from the “larval” stage, which relates to the physical world through consumption, to a “perfect” state in which consumption is less important, and in which freedom and contemplation are the ends of life. This transformational idea rests upon a theory, of dynamic dualism in which the animal and the spiritual self remain in tension, but in which the “maturity” of the individual–transcendence of economic demands as imposed by society–emerges through personal growth based on observation of nature. Thoreau’s dynamic theory of value, and its attractiveness to environmentalists, explains why environmentalists reject the mainstream, neoclassical economic paradigm. This paradigm accepts consumer preferences as “givens” and treats these preferences as the source of all value in their model. Because Thoreau insists that there is value in transformations from one preference set to another, the neoclassical paradigm cannot capture this central value, and cannot account for the environmentalists’ emphasis on public “education” to reduce consumptive demands of humans on their environment.
