Not in My Backyard: The Situational and Personality Determinants of Oppositional Behavior
Author(s)
Thornton, Bill; Knox, Diana
Abstract
The present study considered situational and dispositional factors underlying behavioral opposition characteristic of a “not-in-my-back-yard” (NIMBY) response to a change having adverse personal consequences. Students considered the proposition of comprehensive exams required for graduation taking effect in the near or distant future (high and low vested interest, respectively). Although both groups had similarly negative attitudes toward the idea, the high vested interest group perceived greater personal consequence and expressed greater intention to oppose the plan. From a situational-dispositional interactionist perspective, it was the impact of the situation (perceived stake), rather than personality traits presumed to underlie a NIMBY response, that proved to be the primary determinant of oppositional behavior.
